Car lease
programs in India have grown significantly in the corporate sector over the
past five years. But the growth has not been matched by equivalent clarity
about which businesses benefit and which do not. The decision to lease rather
than buy is not universally correct. It depends on specific factors that most
corporate decision-makers have not evaluated in a structured way.
Why Most Companies
Get This Wrong
The most
common error in the car lease versus purchase decision in India is evaluating
only the monthly payment in isolation. A car lease in India typically requires lower
monthly outflow than a purchase loan for the same vehicle. This comparison is
accurate but incomplete. The relevant comparison is total cost of mobility over
the period, not monthly cash outflow.
Companies
that lease without evaluating usage patterns often pay significantly more per
kilometer than they would under a purchase or reimburse model when they
consistently exceed the mileage limits built into their car lease agreement.
What the Data
Actually Shows
According to KPMG
India Fleet Leasing Market Analysis 2023 companies with employee annual mileage
requirements above 25,000 kilometers per vehicle recover lease costs most
efficiently compared to purchase alternatives. Below this threshold, the
per-kilometer economics of a car lease in India are less consistently
favorable. The crossover point varies by vehicle segment, lease tenure, and the
specific operational model of the business.
A Better Framework
for the Decision
The car lease
decision in India benefits from a structured evaluation across four variables.
First, projected annual mileage per vehicle, compared against the lease
contract's included mileage. Second, total cost of ownership under lease,
including excess mileage charges at the expected usage rate. Third, the value
the business places on predictable monthly costs versus flexibility to modify
the fleet quickly. Fourth, whether maintenance inclusion in the lease removes a
function the business is poorly equipped to manage internally.
Implementation Steps
1.
Calculate your actual annual mileage per vehicle role
for the past 12 months before approaching any car lease provider in India. The
quoted mileage in lease proposals is rarely aligned with actual usage without
this data.
2.
Request total cost of ownership modeling from at least
two lease providers, using your actual mileage data, before comparing against
purchase or reimbursement alternatives.
The Final Question
The right
question about car leasing in India is not whether it is cheaper than buying.
The right question is whether it is the right model for how your specific
organization uses vehicles and manages operational costs.
No comments:
Post a Comment